A judge in Manitoba has thrown out a class-action lawsuit that aimed to secure compensation for grain farmers in the wake of the federal dissolution of the Canadian Wheat Board monopoly, marking what the ruling describes as the final legal action related to this contentious decision made over a decade ago.
In a ruling issued this month, Justice Chris Martin of the Court of King’s Bench dismissed a claim filed in 2017 by farmer Edward Andrew Dennis against the attorney general of Canada and G3 Global Grain Group, which is the new entity succeeding the wheat board.
Established in 1935, the Canadian Wheat Board began as a voluntary marketing initiative before evolving into a mandatory monopoly that required western Canadian farmers to sell their wheat and grain to it, with limited exceptions.
This situation persisted until after the 2011 federal election, when the Conservative government led by then-prime minister Stephen Harper initiated the process of converting the wheat board into a private organization.
Justice Martin noted in his ruling that this move “prompted a series of legal challenges,” with Dennis’s lawsuit being “the last” of those cases.
Agricultural economist Barry Prentice remarked that the ruling signifies “the final chapter” in the saga of the Canadian Wheat Board, suggesting it is time for this chapter to close.
“It caused significant rifts within the agricultural community among farmers, as the issue was deeply felt,” Prentice, who is the director of the University of Manitoba Transport Institute, commented in an interview.
He added, “There were staunch supporters of the wheat board, while others risked imprisonment to transport their grain across the border as a protest against these restrictions on their liberty.”
At rallies in Regina, farmers stand divided on keeping or ending the monopoly of the Canadian Wheat Board in 1994.
Representatives for G3 stated that the ruling “provides closure to a claim that had been pursued through various courts across multiple jurisdictions.”
A spokesperson for the federal government expressed gratitude for the thorough consideration the court has given to this issue.
Legal representatives for the farmers chose not to provide any comments.
Claims of Misfeasance and Breach of Contract
The class action was initiated on behalf of grain farmers who utilized the wheat board’s pool marketing program during the final two years of its monopoly status. The lawsuit centered on the management of funds and specific accounts by the board during that period, as indicated in the ruling.
The claim accused the federal minister overseeing the wheat board of misfeasance in public office and the board itself of breaching contract, seeking damages totaling over $91 million.
Farmers had two avenues for selling their wheat and grain during that time: a pool program, where grain delivered in a specific area was aggregated by type, and a non-pool program.
Farmers using the pool program received an initial payment based on anticipated prices, along with subsequent payments reflecting any increases in value as the product was sold and any financial surplus from the pool. In contrast, non-pool sellers received a larger upfront payment but no additional payments, according to the ruling.
The wheat board was tasked with covering losses from non-pool sales, which meant it maintained a separate contingency fund to allocate profits from non-pool transactions.
This contingency fund had a limit on the amount of money it could hold, and any profits exceeding that limit would revert to a pool account if the fund’s cap was reached. If this contributed to a surplus in the pool account, it would be distributed to producers involved in the pool, as stated in the decision.
The accusation claimed that the minister acted improperly by advising the cabinet to raise the contingency fund limit from $60 million to $100 million and subsequently to $200 million, and by instructing the wheat board to allocate funds to that account.
The farmers contended that leading up to the board’s transition, the fund was effectively utilized “as a general retained earnings account to finance the privatization” of the board.
The claim also alleged that the wheat board violated its contractual commitments to farmers by allocating funds to the contingency account in the fall of 2011 and by utilizing pool account funds to cover expenses associated with the transition to a private grain entity.
Justice Martin rejected these allegations, concluding that the minister acted lawfully and appropriately, there was no binding contract with the farmers, and the board was obliged to cover the costs in question using the pool accounts.
‘No Longer Useful’
Prentice from the University of Manitoba stated that while the wheat board once fulfilled a critical role for farmers, it has “essentially outlived its usefulness” and failed to evolve, a sentiment he believes may also apply to other regulatory frameworks today.
“Some might argue it’s time for a serious review of the supply management program” for products like dairy, eggs, chickens, and turkeys, he suggested.
-
Supply management ‘not on the table,’ says Carney as U.S. bent on changing dairy rules
-
How Canada’s supply management system works
“It’s a politically charged issue, and few are willing to address it directly,” he noted, but “the question always remains … whether it still meets the needs it was originally intended to serve,” according to Prentice.
“While many people support it, others argue that … ‘This is driving up our food costs, and it’s time for it to end.'”


