Residents from the south side of Edmonton are voicing their concerns regarding the naturalization of green spaces in their area, claiming their opinions are being overlooked despite their clear objections.
“We have engaged in discussions with hundreds of residents, and the overwhelming sentiment is one of feeling ignored, frustrated, and quite emotional about this issue,” remarked Rose Herman, a representative of the Windermere and Surrounding Communities Joint Coalition.
“Everyone appreciates the area and frequents it almost daily, and it’s incredibly disheartening that the city seems unwilling to listen to us,” she added.
The City of Edmonton intends to naturalize multiple storm ponds in the Windermere region, which entails allowing landscaped areas to develop into a more organic state with limited upkeep.
According to the city, this initiative aims to protect the natural flora and fauna native to Edmonton.
“Responsible management of parkland involves sustainable practices that foster a healthy, climate-resilient, and livable city for future generations,” the city stated.
Members of the coalition, who oppose the city’s naturalization plans, fear that the community could lose a vital gathering area, that property values may decline due to a poorly maintained environment, and that naturalization could lead to increased encounters with dangerous wildlife, including coyotes.
However, the city’s website claims naturalization offers numerous advantages, such as enhancing surrounding property values, reducing tax spending on landscaping, and improving flood management and temperature control.
A matter of upkeep
Herman noted that many neighborhoods, including parts of Windermere, are supported by homeowners’ associations that fund the maintenance of green spaces through resident fees.
“We actually cover all enhanced maintenance costs, alleviating a significant tax burden from the community at large,” Herman explained. “This effort benefits not only our neighborhood but also those nearby, allowing their residents access to our amenities.”
The city has stated that it will not proceed with naturalization in areas where a homeowners’ association has an active maintenance agreement without prior consultation.
In Edmonton, naturalization implies that certain areas will no longer be regularly mowed, as per the city’s website. Mayor Andrew Knack indicated that naturalized areas can thrive if they are properly maintained.
Everybody loves the space and uses it on almost a daily basis, and the fact that the city does not want to hear from us, it’s very upsetting.Rose Herman
“If we aren’t performing the necessary maintenance, that’s when frustration arises among residents, as I’ve witnessed instances where it appears neglected,” Knack noted, acknowledging the concerns that some Edmontonians have regarding naturalization.
Knack has represented areas that have implemented naturalization efforts and stated he has not seen those spaces become less safe.
He mentioned that many concerns regarding naturalization center around aesthetics, which he considers to be a legitimate issue.
Knack expressed that the city could improve its maintenance of turf and aims to prioritize this in the upcoming municipal budget.
However, concerns extend beyond aesthetics for some residents. Coalition member Reva George stated that naturalization might pose safety risks.
Typically, parents can oversee their children playing in green spaces from their backyards, but naturalization could obstruct those sightlines, she pointed out.
“It removes natural surveillance and creates blind spots,” George explained.

Coalition member Reva George expresses concerns that naturalization could lead to safety problems, particularly for families with children. (Nicole Healey/CBC)
‘A secretive process’
In a statement to CBC News, the city indicated that a majority of participants in its public engagement on naturalization in 2022 and 2023 were supportive of the initiatives.
The city, along with Epcor, asserts that it is making efforts to engage with the community before any planting occurs.
Currently, naturalization projects in Windermere are on hold as plans are being revised and community meetings are being organized. Nonetheless, George expressed dissatisfaction with the city’s consultation process.
She noted that many of the project’s engagement opportunities were not effectively communicated to residents, stating that her group has met with numerous individuals opposed to naturalization, while the city received only 86 responses to its outreach.
“It has been a secretive process,” George asserted.
“We were unaware of it. Our knowledge came from grassroots efforts.”

Mike Elliott, representing Edmonton’s Ward pihêsiwin, is set to meet with residents opposing naturalization to address their concerns. (Nicole Healey/CBC)
Coun. Mike Elliott of Ward pihêsiwin, who plans to meet with the coalition next month, emphasized the importance of clear communication between the city and its residents. He acknowledged that frustrations can arise from delays in reaching out to the appropriate parties.
“This isn’t an isolated issue; multiple neighborhoods are expressing similar concerns about the notification process,” Elliott remarked.
Looking ahead, coalition members aim to collaborate with the city to create an agreeable standard for naturalization, according to George.
“This issue transcends just naturalization and the losses associated; it fundamentally concerns how our southwest community is not being heard or consulted in significant decision-making processes.”
Tag: rewrite-pending

